So, Do You Actually Need AI?

Let's be honest, the amount of hype around AI right now is out of control. Everyone's talking about it. Hell if you look at the last 4 articles we've posted its all about AI. If you're a leader, you're feeling the pressure to have an "AI strategy".

We get it. But here's the trap a lot of companies are falling into: they're grabbing for the shiniest new tool without asking if it's the right one for the job. It’s like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut—overkill, expensive, and frankly, a bit of a mess.

The real conversation isn't about whether AI is "smarter" than automation. That's the wrong way to look at it. The choice is much more fundamental: Are you trying to perfect a process you already know, or are you trying to find answers in a sea of uncertainty? Get that right, and you'll make a smart investment. This guide is meant to help you do just that.

Two Worlds: Certainty vs. Uncertainty

So, how do you know which tool to use? It boils down to two different ways of thinking about a problem. I call them the World of Certainty and the World of Uncertainty.

The World of Certainty: For the things you can predict

This is the home of traditional automation, like Robotic Process Automation (RPA). Think of it as a train on a fixed track. It’s built to follow a strict set of IF/THEN rules you define. For any given input, it does the exact same thing, every time. It’s perfect for those high-volume, repetitive tasks that just need to get done with 100% accuracy—things like processing invoices from a standard template or running payroll. It's your digital workforce for executing known processes flawlessly.

The World of Uncertainty: For the things you can't

This is where AI, especially machine learning, lives. You don't give it a list of rules; you give it a mountain of data and train it to find the patterns on its own. Its job is to make a smart guess—a prediction—when the outcome isn’t a sure thing. This is what you need for tackling complexity and ambiguity, like figuring out what a customer really means in a feedback email or predicting when a piece of machinery is about to fail. It's less about following a script and more about making a judgment call.

The 4 Questions to Ask About Your Problem

Instead of getting bogged down in the tech, just ask yourself a few simple questions about the actual business problem you're trying to solve.

1. Is your process stable, or is it constantly changing?

If the process is stable and the rules don't change—like generating the same weekly report—stick with automation. But if you're in a dynamic situation where things are always evolving, like trying to detect new types of fraud, you'll need the adaptability of AI.

2. Are you trying to execute a task or find an answer?

If the goal is just to get a known process done faster and with fewer mistakes, that’s an automation job. But if you need to

predict something, like future sales, or classify something, like whether a customer email is urgent, you're looking for an insight. That's an AI job.

3. What does your data look like? Neat and tidy or messy and complex?

Automation loves clean, structured data—the kind you find in spreadsheets and databases. But if your problem involves messy, unstructured data like text from customer reviews, images, or audio from a call center, you need AI to make sense of it.

4. Could you draw a flowchart for it?

This is the real litmus test. If you can map out the entire process with clear IF/THEN steps, it’s a perfect candidate for automation. If the process requires judgment, understanding context, or dealing with gray areas, a flowchart won't cut it. You're in AI territory.

The One Thing You Can't Ignore with AI

There's one big catch with AI, though: your data. AI isn't magic; it's a powerful amplifier. If you feed it garbage, it will just give you garbage back, only faster and with more confidence. Before you even think about a big AI project, you have to be honest about the state of your data. Do you have enough of it? Is it high-quality? And critically, is it biased? If your data reflects historical biases in hiring or lending, your AI will learn to be biased, too, and that's a legal and ethical nightmare. Getting your data house in order is a non-negotiable first step.

What Are You Actually Trying to Achieve?

When you boil it all down, the final decision comes down to your strategic goal. The answer usually falls into one of two camps.

Are you looking for incremental improvements?

If you want to make an existing process faster, cheaper, or more accurate, automation is your best bet. It gives you those quick, clear wins and a solid ROI. Think about when Walmart automated its invoice process. They cut processing time in half and paid their vendors faster. They didn't reinvent invoicing; they just made their existing process much, much better. This is about doing the same things, but better.

Or are you looking for a total game-changer?

If your goal is to do something your business has never been able to do before, that's when you bring in AI. AI creates entirely new capabilities. Look at Airbus. They used AI to design a cabin partition that was 45% lighter than any human had designed, but just as strong. That wasn't just an improvement; it was a fundamental shift in how they engineer parts, saving huge amounts in fuel and emissions. This is about doing new things that were not possible before.

Start with the Problem, Not the Tech

So, next time someone on your team says, "we need an AI strategy," the right response is to ask, "What problem are we actually trying to solve?" Don't start with the tech; start with the challenge. Figure out if you're living in the world of certainty or the world of uncertainty.

Use automation to nail the predictable stuff and free up your people and your budget. Then, you can point your AI investments at the big, hairy, uncertain problems—the ones that, if you solve them, could really change the game for your business.

‍